Which Charmer would you kill off?

In the spirit of sparking a little activity around here, here's a cruel little poll posing the question: 'if you had to kill off one of the Charmers, who would it be?' And explain why or why not the others.

To figure this out myself, I pictured pointing a gun at each Charmer, and ended up decided I would kill off Wynn if I had to...

It physically hurt me to consider killing Lyna, I just couldn't do it.

I've caused Eria too much suffering in my fanfic as it is, I couldn't possibly compound that by killing her off.

Surprisingly, it was easier to consider killing off Hiita or Dharc, but they're still my top two favorite Charmers, so I just couldn't in the end.

Which put me down to two, but I'm not really sure what pulled Aussa out over Wynn, but it was my final decision.



And please feel free to express how horrible I am for posing this question in your response!

Now this is a bizarre thread.


Among all of the charmers, I'll choose... well, Wynn.  


Yes, Wynn. It will give the most emotional effect in a story. Would be fun right....... Runo? ( '3')

Spoiler:

Wow... that's quite a disturbing question. What's even more disturbing is that I can think of more than one way to answer it.

If you mean which Charmer would I personally kill if I was forced to do the killing myself: I hate to say this, but I would pick Dharc. The girls are all too dear to my heart for me to kill, and with Dharc out of the way maybe I can replace him in the harem!

If you mean which Charmer would I have killed off as part of a story/plotline: Lyna, most likely. I feel that her death would invoke the most emotional response from the other characters, coupled with her purity and innocence being a key factor in maintaining balance, and with that balance lost comes a more disruptive conflict.

And if you mean which Charmer would I have removed from the archetype in the card game: Lyna again. She was the newest one, and has always been the odd one out. She has no FP-form, and her Spiritual Art seemed kinda forced. Even her artwork is slightly different in style from the other 5.

2 out of 3 choices means I must pick Lyna in the poll. But you really should sit in the corner and think about what you've done, Binding Dharc

Personally? Aussa. Out of all the charmers, she is the one I never really thought of as special or specifically significant. She is the one I would most likely kill off simply because it doesnt make much difference to me (although Hiita would lose her vitriolic bud in my headcanon, huh...).

Eria all the way, since she's dead to begin with(good ol'Gagagigo story happen all thanks to this 'small' event after all) :v

Tho, Wyrn dead could also spark some stuff up, like the reason Petit Dragon become one of the FGD or stuff :3

Aussa - unexpected death
Eria - story-plot-calling-it death
Hiita - heroic death
Wynn - saddening death
Dharc - tragic death
Lyna - funny death

So, Lyna.